Surgical malpractice in New York is a significant concern, particularly when it involves errors stemming from malfunctioning or improperly maintained surgical equipment. Hospitals, surgical centers, and other medical facilities have a legal duty to ensure that their equipment is properly maintained, regularly inspected, and safe for use. When this duty is neglected, patients can suffer devastating and sometimes life-threatening injuries.
In New York, victims of such surgical errors have legal recourse under the state’s medical malpractice laws, which allow them to seek compensation for their injuries and losses. An experienced New York City medical malpractice attorney can prove liability of the negligent surgeon and hospital, and recover maximum damages for the injured patient and their family.
Importance of Properly Functioning Surgical Equipment
Modern surgical procedures rely heavily on the precision and reliability of advanced equipment. Surgical tools, robotic systems, anesthesia machines, and other medical devices are crucial in ensuring patient safety and successful outcomes.
Even a minor malfunction or defect in these instruments can cause significant harm, leading to prolonged surgeries, additional injuries, or life-threatening complications. Proper maintenance of these tools is essential not only to their function but also to maintaining the sterility necessary to prevent infection and other postoperative complications.
How Equipment Malfunctions in New York Hospitals Lead to Surgical Errors
Malfunctions in surgical equipment can occur at various stages of an operation, often without warning. The following are some ways in which equipment failures or maintenance issues can cause serious surgical errors:
Power Failures in Electronic Surgical Devices
Many surgeries rely on electronic devices like cauterization machines, robotic surgery tools, and laser technology. A sudden power failure in these devices can cause incomplete procedures or accidental damage to tissues, blood vessels, or organs. For example, if a cauterization machine loses power while sealing a blood vessel, it could result in uncontrollable bleeding, placing the patient in danger.
Faulty or Miscalibrated Equipment
Instruments such as scalpels, bone saws, or drills require precise calibration to function correctly. A miscalibrated tool can cause excessive cutting or drilling, leading to damage beyond the intended surgical area. In laparoscopic procedures, improperly calibrated cameras or lights can obscure the surgeon's view, increasing the likelihood of error.
Sterilization Failures
Improper maintenance or cleaning of surgical instruments can lead to infections, including life-threatening conditions like sepsis. Equipment used during surgery must be thoroughly sterilized before each procedure. Failure to properly clean and sterilize surgical tools can introduce bacteria into the patient's body, causing infections that may be difficult to treat.
Robotic Surgery Malfunctions
Robotic-assisted surgeries have become increasingly popular due to their precision. However, when a robotic system malfunctions, it can lead to surgical errors such as damaging critical organs, nerves, or blood vessels. A system malfunction in the middle of a procedure can cause the robot’s arms or tools to move unexpectedly, leading to severe complications.
Causes of Surgical Equipment Failures in New York Hospitals
Several factors contribute to the malfunction or improper maintenance of surgical equipment. Common causes include:
Legal Implications of Surgical Errors Due to Equipment Malfunctions
Victims of surgical malpractice involving malfunctioning or improperly maintained equipment have the right to file a medical malpractice claim in New York. To prevail in such a case, the patient must prove that the hospital or medical staff failed to provide a reasonable standard of care, and this failure directly caused their injuries.
These claims can be complex and require extensive evidence, including medical records, expert testimony, and detailed explanations of how the equipment failure led to the surgical error. Make sure you have a skilled and experienced NYC surgical negligence attorney on your side to pursue maximum damages for your injuries and losses.
Negligence in Equipment Maintenance
Hospitals and medical centers are responsible for ensuring that their equipment is regularly maintained, inspected, and safe for use. Failure to meet these obligations can be considered negligence. If a surgical error occurred because equipment was not adequately maintained or malfunctioned due to lack of proper care, the hospital may be held liable for the patient’s injuries.
Negligence in Equipment Operation
If the error was caused by a healthcare professional’s improper use of surgical equipment, they and the hospital could be held liable. For example, if a surgeon fails to notice that an instrument is malfunctioning during surgery or uses a device inappropriately, leading to harm, this may be grounds for a medical malpractice claim.
Product Liability for Defective Equipment
In cases where the malfunction was due to a defect in the equipment itself, the equipment’s manufacturer could be held liable under New York product liability laws. This can occur if the equipment was designed or manufactured improperly, or if the manufacturer failed to warn medical staff about potential risks associated with the device.
Examples of Surgical Errors in New York City Hospitals Due to Equipment Malfunction
Anesthesia Machine Failures Resulting in Oxygen Deprivation
In one case, an anesthesia machine malfunctioned during surgery, delivering an incorrect mix of oxygen and anesthetic gases to the patient. This led to oxygen deprivation (hypoxia), causing the patient to suffer brain damage. Oxygen levels were not restored quickly enough, leading to permanent cognitive impairment.
Robotic Surgery Arm Malfunctions
Robotic-assisted surgeries are increasingly common, but malfunctions in the robotic arm can have devastating consequences. In one case, the robotic arm unexpectedly moved beyond the intended range, damaging a patient's blood vessels and causing severe internal bleeding. The surgeon had to abandon the robotic procedure and switch to manual surgery, but the patient sustained significant injury.
Endoscopic Equipment Failure During Gastrointestinal Surgery
Endoscopic equipment is used to navigate the digestive tract during minimally invasive surgeries. In one incident, the endoscope's lighting system malfunctioned, leaving the surgeon unable to see clearly. This led to accidental perforation of the patient’s intestine, which resulted in severe infection (peritonitis) and required emergency surgery.
Faulty Defibrillator Leads to Cardiac Complications
During a heart surgery, a malfunctioning defibrillator failed to deliver the correct electrical charge, preventing the surgeon from properly resuscitating the patient’s heart. The equipment failure delayed the resumption of normal cardiac function, causing long-term heart damage and significantly increasing the risk of future cardiac events.
Ultrasonic Scalpel Malfunction Causing Excessive Bleeding
Ultrasonic scalpels are often used to cut tissue with minimal blood loss. However, in one instance, the ultrasonic scalpel malfunctioned, failing to coagulate blood vessels as intended. This led to uncontrolled bleeding during surgery, putting the patient at risk of hemorrhagic shock and requiring multiple blood transfusions.
Power Drill Malfunctions Leading to Bone Fractures
In orthopedic surgeries, power drills are often used to fixate screws and plates in bones. In one case, a malfunctioning surgical drill unexpectedly increased in speed, causing the surgeon to drill too deeply into the bone, resulting in a fracture. The patient required additional surgery to repair the damage, which extended recovery time and increased the risk of infection.
Malfunctioning Suction Device Leading to Fluid Accumulation
Suction devices are critical in clearing blood and fluids during surgery. In one case, a malfunctioning suction device failed to remove blood efficiently, causing fluid accumulation in the surgical area. This impaired the surgeon’s visibility and led to accidental damage to surrounding tissues. The patient developed post-operative complications, including an abscess and infection.
Inaccurate Vital Signs Monitor During Critical Surgery
Vital signs monitors are crucial for tracking a patient’s heart rate, blood pressure, and oxygen levels during surgery. In one case, the monitor malfunctioned, providing inaccurate readings, which led the surgical team to miss signs of declining blood pressure. By the time the error was recognized, the patient had gone into shock, requiring emergency intervention and a prolonged stay in the ICU.
Failed Laparoscopic Procedures
In one instance, a patient underwent a laparoscopic surgery that required precise camera and instrument placement. Due to a faulty camera, the surgeon's view was compromised, causing damage to surrounding organs. The patient suffered severe complications, including internal bleeding, and required multiple follow-up surgeries.
Burn Injuries from Malfunctioning Laser Equipment
In another case, a laser used during surgery malfunctioned, emitting excessive heat. This caused the patient to suffer third-degree burns on surrounding tissues and skin, leading to permanent disfigurement.
Steps Hospitals Should Take to Avoid Equipment Malfunctions
To reduce the risk of surgical errors caused by equipment failure, hospitals and surgical centers must implement the following safety protocols:
Get Strong Legal Representation from Skilled and Resourceful NYC Surgical Malpractice Lawyers
If you or a loved one has suffered injuries due to a surgical error, you need the experienced legal team at Rosenberg, Minc, Falkoff & Wolff, LLP on your side. Our New York City medical malpractice attorneys have recovered over $1 billion for injured New Yorkers and our success rate is over 95%.
With four generations of experience in medical malpractice claims, we know the devastating effects surgical negligence can have on your life. Whether your case involves a preventable mistake, equipment failure, or improper care, our top-rated surgical negligence attorneys in New York will fight to recover the highest compensation for you.
When you choose our NYC medical malpractice attorneys at Rosenberg, Minc, Falkoff & Wolff, LLP, you are choosing a dedicated legal team with a proven track record of success in surgical malpractice cases. We will leave no stone unturned in investigating your claim, using all available resources to build a strong case for maximum financial recovery.
Let us help you hold negligent healthcare providers accountable, while you focus on healing. To schedule your free consultation, call us at 212-344-1000 or contact us online.
MANHATTAN LAW OFFICE
122 East 42nd Street Suite 3800
New York, NY 10168
Tel: 212-LAWYERS
Tel: 212-697-9280
QUEENS LAW OFFICE
8900 Sutphin Blvd Suite 501
Queens, NY 11435
Tel: (718) 399-3100
*By Appointment Only